But the Trump administration’s plan to put a citizenship question back on the US census is a big deal.
Even if talk about polls and statistics usually makes your eyes glaze over, here’s why you should pay attention:
The census isn’t just an academic exercise. It’s the basis for deciding the number of representatives each state gets in Congress and how billions of dollars in federal funds are distributed.
Here’s a look at the issues at play — and what’s at stake:
Why is this coming up now?
The Justice Department asked officials to add the citizenship question, saying it needed better data on the voting age population to help enforce the Voting Rights Act. In a memo
Monday, Secretary of Commerce Wilbur Ross, whose department runs the census, said he was granting the Justice Department’s request.
Supporters say this is a common-sense question that simply makes sense to ask.
Critics argue that the Justice Department has other ways to get citizenship data without interfering with the census. They say the change is a political decision aimed at shifting the balance of power — and that it’s no coincidence administration officials made the push to add a question that runs the risk of significantly undercounting immigrant, minority and low-income populations.
What exactly are critics concerned about?
Advocates fear that when undocumented immigrants or people in immigrant families receive the census form in the mail, the citizenship question will stop them from completing and returning it.
Immigrant rights groups say this couldn’t come at a worse time, as many in immigrant communities are already losing trust in officials and afraid to answer their doors.
“In the past, the census would always make a big effort to tell people that they don’t share their information with other government agencies. I think that’s something people will not take too seriously this time,” said William Frey, a demographer and senior fellow at the Brookings Institution.
Demographers and other experts — including several former directors of the census
— have warned that adding a citizenship question could result in reduced response rates and inaccurate answers.
In his memo outlining the decision, Ross said he’d weighed concerns about an undercount, but didn’t see enough evidence showing that the citizenship question would materially decrease response rates.
“I find that the need for accurate citizenship data and the limited burden that the reinstatement of the citizenship question would impose outweigh fears about a potentially lower response rate,” he wrote.
Who is the census supposed to count?
The decennial census is supposed to count everyone who lives in the United States, whether or not they are citizens.
That data is used to calculate all sorts of things, including the number of representatives each state gets in Congress, the number of votes each state gets in the Electoral College and the amount of federal funding local governments get for programs like Medicaid, Head Start and the National School Lunch Program
Are certain geographic areas more likely to lose representatives in Congress or federal funding?
The 2020 census is still years away. And it’s too soon to say for certain how things will play out.
But if response rates drop significantly, some states could find themselves losing a House seat or federal funding.
States with large immigrant populations like Texas, California, Florida, New Jersey, New York and Illinois could be affected, Frey said.
But it’s important to note that population trends have shifted in recent years beyond these traditional gateways. Significant growth in immigrant populations has occurred largely in the Southeast, from small towns in rural communities to bigger cities like Charlotte, North Carolina, and Atlanta.
States like Georgia and North Carolina could see an impact, too, Frey said.
What are the political implications of this?
Even before the Commerce Department’s announcement, the 2020 census was becoming a political flashpoint.
President Trump’s re-election campaign sent an email to supporters last week, endorsing the idea of adding a citizenship question and slamming opponents of the move.
“The President wants the 2020 United States census to ask people whether or not they are citizens. In another era, this would be COMMON SENSE … but 19 attorneys general said they will fight the President if he dares to ask people if they are citizens. The President wants to know if you’re on his side,” the email said.
Democratic lawmakers fired back on Tuesday
, slamming the administration.
“Trump is worried about losing power so he’s trying to take ours away,” California Rep. Lucille Roybal-Allard said on Twitter.
Hasn’t this question been on the census before?
Yes, but not since 1950.
For years, however, it has appeared on the American Community Survey
, an ongoing sample survey conducted by the Census Bureau.
It’s no surprise to see census questions shifting with the times, said Margo J. Anderson, a professor of history at the University of Wisconsin, Milwaukee.
“It was a big deal to ask if someone had a radio in 1930. In 1940, not so much,” she said.
Citizenship questions were regularly on the census until 1950. In 1960, they were removed from the list.
“Lots of questions go off the census when they’re not very important anymore,” Anderson said. “In 1960, we had essentially had very low levels of immigration for 30-35 years. … There weren’t very many new immigrants coming. When you started collecting the data, there wasn’t much to find out.”
A citizenship question reappeared in 1970 on the long-form questionnaire sent to a sample of households at the time.
“We passed major new immigration legislation in 1965, and so the question became relevant again,” Anderson said.
It remained on subsequent long-form questionnaires until they were discontinued after 2000. It became part of the American Community Survey, which the Census Bureau began using to collect more detailed household data in 2005.
So is this a done deal?
The state of California immediately challenged the plan, filing a lawsuit in federal court on Tuesday. Former Obama administration Attorney General Eric Holder also blasted the move and said his organization, which focuses on voting enfranchisement and redistricting, would also pursue litigation against what he called an “irresponsible decision.”
And some Democratic lawmakers are also trying to block the move in Congress.
This much is clear: With immigration increasingly a political flashpoint and midterm elections looming, debate about this controversial census question is just beginning.
CNN’s Tal Kopan, Steve Brusk and Gregory Wallace contributed to this report.
100 thoughts on “ARE YOU A CITIZEN? THE QUESTION UPSETS THE CRIME SYNDICATE OF SANCTUARY STATES”
side effects of hydroxychloroquine chloroquine phosphate online
generic chloroquine https://hydroxychloroquinetc.com/
can hydroxychloroquine be purchased over the counter chloroquine buy on line
zithromax online price of zithromax
926333 133177i was just browsing along and came upon your site. just wantd to say excellent job and this post genuinely helped me. 656516
price of lasix
zithromax buy generic zithromax
cheap cialis in usa
genuine cialis tablets
female viagra tablets in india
generic viagra 50
tadalafil walmart cialis generic 2017 cialis generic drug
buy generic cialis online canada
sildenafil 50mg buy
ampicillin online order
best price for viagra in us
viagra 50mg tablet
where can i buy cheap viagra
abilify 5mg tab
viagra from canadian pharmacy
tadalafil 22 mg
stromectol ivermectin 3 mg ivermectin 3 mg tabs stromectol 3mg
best price malegra fxt usa
viagra prescription australia
doxycycline 100 mg buy online
I’m not sure exactly why but this weblog is loading extremely
slow for me. Is anyone else having this issue or is it
a issue on my end? I’ll check back later on and see if the problem still
disulfiram uk prescription
[url=http://mysildenafilshop.com/]buy sildenafil citrate 100mg[/url]
canadian pharmacies without prescriptions over the counter online pharmacy bernie sanders canada drugs
sildenafil 100mg coupon
canadian pharmacies best canadian drugs pharmacies online
Hi, of course this paragraph is truly pleasant and I have learned lot
of things from it about blogging. thanks.
[url=http://genericcialis20tablet.monster/]buy brand name cialis online[/url]
where can i buy viagra pills
cialis canada pharmacy
My relatives has been flourishing to the azithromycin z pack cost since we moved to Cloverdale 24 years ago, and I wouldnвЂ™t mirage of going anywhere else. They from as a last resort charmed moving protection of all of us, they know us all by rating, and they are each time there to rejoinder any of our medicament or trim concerns with their masterly knowledge. I pleasure their ordinary seminars and love how snarled in the community they are. If IвЂ™m ever asked I have and always choice stand up for Cloverdale Pharmasave. There artlessly is no elevate surpass place!
cheap generic cialis uk
ivermectin cream cost
azithromycin generic brand – Not an eye to the before chance I was not listened to. Yes, problems with organized whole which led to 2 alike resemble prescriptions. Fellow of cane refused to listen and made unhelpful presumptions. When all is said and reluctantly allowed both parts of the prescription. Not helpful.
buy ivermectin nz
where to get viagra online
zithromax price z pack azithromycin without a doctor’s prescription
ventolin hfa inhaler side effects – warnings for ventolin hfa
Wonderful forum posts. With thanks.
avodart uk prescription
paxil brain zaps
where can i buy female viagra in india
Buyer assignment was tactful and without delay responded to my questions. Coming from another company hfaventolin that wont be named this was a delicious change. Will be ordering again!
Wonderful stuff. Kudos.
накрутка зрителей твич
stromectol lotion cost otcstromectol.com ivermectin for humans dosage
Would not us this vendor again. So tons things made it naughty to piece with kamagrapls. Mostly, truly poor communication. Incredible all kinds of wonderful knowledge.
Unadorned and cheap ivermectin for humans object of ordering your communication lenses online. My lenses were fortunately in forebear and shipped immediately. Spoke to a very nice better half on the phone who was happy to surrebutter my questions and a leading perpetually user.
Many thanks. I like this.
cialis how to get
mebendazole goodrx mebendazole back on the market mebendazole treatment for pinworm
stromectol ivermectin 1 10 ml ivermectin tablets
of course, diamond rings would always be the best type of wedding rings that you can give your wife;;
frontline doctors and hydroxychloroquine website how to get hydroxychloroquine prescription hydroxy
cialis from india – Sent in my order when I placed my serenity online and received an email with my tracking slew the UNMODIFIED time! Great facts, Thank you!
online cialis canada
hydroxychloroquine cost without insurance hydroxychloroquine online free natural hydroxychloroquine
sildenafil discount generic
Got a pure accept on this medicated shampoo. Was delivered in a timely fashion. Restful to play the buying viagra.
hydroxychloroquine price increase hydroxychloroquine 200 mg tab tablet hydroxychloroquine for sale amazon
It was the beginning conditions I ordered from z pack. It was a likeable experience. Lofty communication and wonderful extravagantly shipping. I was unquestionably surprised I can acquire my order the next daytime payment a completely logical value, and I did receive it on conditions! I’ a happy customer. Incredible many of helpful material.
atarax pill color hydroxyzine for anxiety attacks atarax 25mg for sleep
boost followers Twitch
My one’s own flesh has been prospering to the ivermectinhumans.com since we moved to Cloverdale 24 years ago, and I wouldnвЂ™t fantasy of prevalent anywhere else. They from on all occasions captivated awe-inspiring care of all of us, they remember us all nearby call, and they are usually there to fit any of our drug or salubriousness concerns with their trained knowledge. I love their frequent seminars and thing embrace how convoluted in the community they are. If IвЂ™m till the end of time asked I have and always wish acceptable Cloverdale Pharmasave. There entirely is no better place! Really loads of great data.
Izleyicileri artД±rД±n Twitch
Buy Twitch Viewers
buy valtrex without a prescription
The two pharmacists were very welcoming, veteran and helpful! I crave I was authorised to name their individual names on this website! They provided me with a flu vaccination that I was unfit to subsist via my doctor (peaceful though the yourself I live with has a compromised immune scheme). sildenafil 100 mg are going upon and beyond to shield the undetailed popular and their kinfolk members during a uncertain time. Thank you. Awesome stuff.
buy cialis through paypal
My wife and I changed our nominated drugstore to Dale’s in Lull Ferry approximately harmonious year ago. Having experienced their usefulness with a view that duration it has confirmed that it was a discerning move. The consumer service is excellent: knowledgeable, congenial, profitable and efficient. The automatic pharmaceutical chemist has supported us in a whizz manner and often “gone the extra mile” to help. Dale doctorborat.com is a unequalled colloid of obsolete fashioned buyer assistance with all the advantages that modish technology has to offer. We would both well recommend it. Seriously plenty of fantastic knowledge.
viagra prices viagra pill what not to take with viagra
stromectol 6mg ivermectin tablets dosage
303523 170665Thank you for your details and respond to you. auto loans westvirginia 789387
643067 542366Couldn?t be designed any far better. Reading this post reminds me of my old room mate! He always kept talking about this. I will forward this report to him. Pretty certain he will possess a good read. Thanks for sharing! 31577
sildenafil 100 mg tablet https://viawithoutdctrs.com/
brand viagra https://mrviadoc.com/
https://mrviadoc.com/ where to buy herbal viagra
https://pharmduck.com/ acid reflux medication over the counter
ivermectin for humans for sale https://stromectl.com/
sildenafil review https://viawithoutdctrs.com/
https://mrviadoc.com/ sildenafil 20 mg
https://cialiswen.com/ buying cialis cheap
erythromycin for gastroparesis
Comments are closed.